The Oldest City in Arizona: A Tale Of Tucson and Phoenix
The cities of Tucson and Phoenix in the state of Arizona have a long-standing rivalry that goes beyond just sports. One of the most significant debates surrounding the two is the question of which city is older. The answer may not be as straightforward as initially thought, as it involves parsing through historical documents and archaeological evidence to determine the exact age of each city.
Tucson: The Oldest City in Arizona
Tucson’s claim to be the oldest city in Arizona rests on its history as a Spanish colonial outpost established in 1775. The city takes great pride in this claim, and even goes as far as to use the moniker “The Old Pueblo” as a nod to its colonial roots.
However, the timeline of when each city was established does not necessarily tell the whole story. There is evidence to suggest that the area now known as Phoenix has been inhabited for much longer than just 150 years.
The Hohokam: Early Inhabitants of the Phoenix Area
Archaeological finds in the Salt River Valley, where Phoenix now sits, show evidence of human habitation dating back thousands of years. Native American tribes, including the Hohokam, inhabited the area from at least 300 BC until around 1450 AD. The remains of their settlements, including pithouses, ballcourts, and irrigation systems, can still be seen today.
But does the existence of Native American settlements in the area prior to European colonization necessarily make Phoenix older than Tucson? Not necessarily. The distinction between human habitation and the establishment of a colonial outpost is essential. While Phoenix may have been an important location for Native American tribes, it was not until the Spanish established a fort in Tucson that the area became a formal outpost of Spain. This distinction is why Tucson is considered the oldest city in the state.
Phoenix: Newer Than Tucson But with a Rich History
Additionally, while the Hohokam were a significant presence in the Salt River Valley, the area was abandoned shortly before European colonization. It was not until the late 1800s, when the Swilling Irrigation Canal was constructed, that the area once again became an attractive location for settlement. This means that Phoenix, as we know it today, did not truly exist until much later than Tucson.
Of course, there are those in Phoenix who dispute Tucson’s claim to being the oldest city in Arizona. They point to the fact that Phoenix is now the state’s largest and most populous city, and that it has played a more significant role in Arizona’s modern history. However, these factors do not change the facts about the history of each city.
Respecting and Understanding History
Ultimately, the debate over which city is older than the other is one that comes down to the distinction between human habitation and the establishment of a formal settlement. While the Salt River Valley may have been inhabited for thousands of years, it was not until the establishment of a Spanish colonial outpost in Tucson that the area became a formal settlement. For this reason, Tucson is considered the oldest city in Arizona.
However, it is essential to acknowledge and appreciate the Native American history that existed in the area before European colonization. The Hohokam people’s legacy can still be seen in the region today, and their contributions should not be overlooked or forgotten.
In the end, the debate over which city is older may seem trivial, but it speaks to a broader issue of the importance of respecting and understanding history correctly. By unraveling the mystery of which city is older, we can gain a more nuanced view of the state’s history and appreciate the contributions of all those who have contributed to its development over time.
————————————